App Wars

New axisReader vs. old OverDrive

Following Hachette’s press release about their new offers to libraries, Overdrive, Baker and Taylor and 3M announced that they would be the distributors of Hachette’s 5000 or so digital titles. I am very familiar with Overdrive, but was interested in learning more about the others. There are so many ebook distributors I didn’t know about, such as…

I became familiar with Overdrive for the purpose of assisting patrons, but I definitely use it myself now as well. Earlier this month The Digital Reader announced that Baker and Taylor had a new app for library eBooks: axisReader. This new reading application has the usual dictionary, search, bookmark, but it also allows sharing via social media. This is something I had never encountered in Overdrive. With axisReader you can share any favourite quotes right onto Facebook and Twitter. According to the article, you can also customize everything from your background (including night mode), to themes, line spacing and font.

It is no surprise then, that on May 28th OverDrive will be releasing a new version of their app. Version 2.6.5 is not only concentrated on fixing some bugs, but is going to compete with axisReader by enhancing other features. Upon opening the app, OverDrive is promoting their “performance improvements”. They list the following:

  1. Adjust your reading experience with the optional multi-column view
  2. Pan and zoom charts and images in eBooks using the image viewer
  3. Change the font style with bold fonts
  4. The eBooks reader now includes sliding page transitions
  5. A new, redesigned audiobook player
  6. Browse library titles in the app for OverDrive-powered sites
  7. OverDrive Media Console uses Google Analytics to compile anonymous usage data (unsure if the public wants to know they are always being surveyed)
  8. Share your opinions with other book lovers on Goodreads

I like the new developments, and can appreciate their attempt at improving the “user experience”. Nevertheless, reading apps such as these, which will be used in libraries, need to focus more so on clarity and functionality, and less on fancy features. The more options and buttons crowding the already small reading platform, the more the content is overshadowed. I also would question the necessity of social media links. Personally Twitter and Facebook would pull me out of my reading. Not okay.

All in all, I might download axisReader. You know, for market research.